AmiBroker vs Trade Ideas (2026)
AmiBroker (windows desktop platform for high-speed portfolio backtesting in the afl language) and Trade Ideas (ai stock scanner with no-code oddsmaker backtesting and broker auto-execution) solve backtesting differently. The table below compares them on verified specs and pricing; full details are in each review.
Side by side
| AmiBroker | Trade Ideas | |
|---|---|---|
| Overall score | 7.8 / 10 | 5.4 / 10 |
| Engine type | hybrid | visual/no-code |
| Pricing model | one-time | subscription |
| Free tier | Yes | Yes |
| Entry price | $0 | $0 |
| Languages | AFL (AmiBroker Formula Language), C++ (plugin ADK), JScript/VBScript (OLE automation) | no-code |
| Asset classes | stocks, ETFs, futures, forex, mutual funds, crypto (via imported data) | US stocks, ETFs, Canadian stocks |
| Bundled data | No market data is bundled. The AmiQuote companion app (included in the Ultimate Pack, $99 standalone) downloads free EOD data from Yahoo Finance and Stooq, plus limited free intraday from Barchart OnDemand. Paid sources (Tiingo, eSignal, IQFeed, Norgate, Interactive Brokers) plug in when you need higher quality. | Real-time US and Canadian equity market data on paid tiers (15-min delayed on the free plan). The backtest database holds roughly 40-64 trading days of 1-minute OHLC alert history |
| Finest resolution | tick (Professional edition, with a tick-capable feed such as eSignal or Interactive Brokers); Standard edition is limited to minute bars | minute (backtests run on 1-min OHLC; live alerts stream tick-based) |
| Live trading | Yes | Yes |
| Options support | No | No |
| Open source | No | No |
AmiBroker
Windows desktop platform for high-speed portfolio backtesting in the AFL language
Trade Ideas
AI stock scanner with no-code OddsMaker backtesting and broker auto-execution
Frequently asked questions
Is AmiBroker better than Trade Ideas?+
They target different users. AmiBroker: systematic eod and swing traders on windows who want the fastest affordable portfolio-level backtesting and optimization, own their data pipeline, and don't need turnkey live execution or options modeling. Trade Ideas: discretionary us-equity day traders who want ai-generated scan setups with quick, no-code sanity-check backtests and hands-off broker execution. quants who need multi-year, tick-accurate validation should look elsewhere. Our scores: AmiBroker 7.8/10, Trade Ideas 5.4/10.
Which is cheaper, AmiBroker or Trade Ideas?+
AmiBroker entry pricing: $0 (one-time). Trade Ideas: $0 (subscription). See each review for full verified pricing tables.
Educational content only, not investment advice. Specs and prices come from each platform's official pages; see the individual reviews for sources and last-verified dates.